How I went from stock picker to ETF investor
I have made just about every mistake you can make when investing. Some cost me my nerves, some cost me a lot of money. This is my story and what I learned from it.

Fiat, at twelve
I bought my first share at the age of twelve, in 1985: Fiat. I no longer remember exactly why it had to be Fiat. But I do remember how exciting it was to check the share price in the newspaper every day. And we are talking about a printed daily paper with a box for the various stock prices. For a while I even cut them out and filed them away. A company belonged, just a tiny bit, to me. That fascination has never left me. My father sold the Fiat shares back then at a small profit; the next share was AEG. Unfortunately, that one did not go so well. Never mind, I was hooked.
What I did not know back then: I had got used to seeing investing as a game. As a search for the one share that beats all the others. That attitude cost me a great deal over the next twenty years.
The Neuer Markt: paying for my lessons on a grand scale
By the end of the nineties I was a convinced stock picker. Germany’s Neuer Markt was booming, new technology companies went public every month and share prices knew only one direction. I read reports, followed ad hoc announcements on n-tv with my mother and was sure I could spot the winners earlier than others. On top of that, I had secured shares in a start-up through a friends-and-family programme, which easily gained 100% on the first day of trading. Good times.
Then the bubble burst. Many of the companies I had believed to be the future lost most of their value or disappeared altogether. I lost a lot of money back then. Looking back, more painful than the loss was the realisation: I had not been unlucky. I had been speculating and mistaken it for knowledge.
The next round of mistakes: expensive advice
After the crash I wanted to do things properly, sought outside advice and kept my hands off shares for a while. The result: contracts that were mainly good for the intermediary. Unit-linked life insurance policies with high acquisition costs, actively managed funds with front-end loads and a Riester pension contract whose costs ate up a large part of the state subsidies.
Nobody had lied to me. But nobody had explained how heavily ongoing costs weigh on returns over decades. Or that my adviser earned the most when I signed as many of these products as possible (fair enough, I only realised that afterwards).
The turning point: investing as a science
Around 15 years ago I started to take the subject seriously. Not with tips and forecasts, but with research. As for many people in Germany, it began with a book by Gerd Kommer, the classic Souverän investieren mit Indexfonds und ETFs. Other books followed, some more philosophical, such as “How to Think About Money” by Jonathan Clements (still one of my favourites, by the way), or practical ones like Nikolaus Braun’s “Über Geld nachdenken”.
The result was sobering and liberating at the same time. Over long periods, most professional fund managers fail to beat their benchmark after costs. According to the SPIVA report by S&P Dow Jones Indices, around 98% of active global equity funds in euros lagged their benchmark over the ten years to the end of 2025; for European equity funds it was 97%. If professionals with entire research departments cannot do it, why should I manage it with a newspaper and gut feeling?
What I do differently today
My portfolio is boring today, and that is intentional:
- Broad diversification instead of individual bets: Most of it is in low-cost index funds covering thousands of companies worldwide, in developed and emerging markets.
- An eye on costs: Ongoing costs of a few tenths of a percent instead of 1.5 to 2% a year. Over 20 years, that makes up a large part of the result.
- A buffer for bad years: Several years of expenses are held in the money market. When the market falls, I do not have to sell.
- A plan instead of reactions: I know how much I invest, how my wealth is allocated and when I rebalance. The news does not change that.
- Calculating instead of hoping: I check whether my plan holds up with simulations that also play through bad market years. I explain how this works in Monte Carlo simulation explained simply.
I still own a few individual shares. For the fun of it, not as a strategy, and with a clearly limited share.
Five lessons from 40 years in the stock market
- Excitement does not drive returns. My most exciting investments were my worst.
- Costs are the only certain figure. Returns are uncertain; costs arise every year.
- Ask how your adviser is paid. The answer often explains more than any presentation.
- Diversification beats conviction. Nobody knows which companies will lead in 20 years.
- A plan keeps you calm in a crisis. If you know why you invest, you don’t sell in a panic.
Conclusion: a hobby became a profession
Today I pass on what I would have wished for myself 25 years ago: an honest look at your own finances, without product sales and with numbers instead of gut feeling, using simulations that also work through bad market years. If you recognise yourself in my story, that is no cause for concern. It is the best moment to do things differently.
Try it yourselfWill my money last? The free calculatorCalculate now →General information, not investment or tax advice. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results.